Letty Stott
Many readers will be aware of the recent discovery of the ‘Norfolk Carnyx’, and when the BBC’s Digging for Britain programme wanted an ancient horn expert to interview, there was only one person to talk to. Letty Stott is a freelance horn player, Head of Performance at Wells Cathedral School and is currently studying for a PhD in Music Archaeology at Manchester University and National Museums Scotland. The Horn Player editor, Richard Steggall, wanted to find out more, so met up with Letty to discuss the carnyx, ancient horns and blockbuster films.
Is ‘ancient horn player’ the correct term?
As the years progress, I’m worried that someone’s going to say ‘she’s an ancient horn player’ and they'll expect me to be a very old lady! Anyway, yes, I’m a horn player who plays specialist forms of horn, some of which happen to be replica or analogue copies of ancient instruments.
The timing of this find seems to be perfect for your current research.
I couldn't possibly have asked for anything better during my PhD! The Norfolk Carnyx is a spectacular, once-in-many-lifetimes type of discovery.
What were they looking for when it was uncovered?
It was part of a housing construction site, which seems to be how a lot of amazing archaeology is found. It was a chance find and the carnyx could easily have been torn to pieces (what an awful thought!) by machinery on the site. It’s currently undergoing conservation work in Norwich Castle museum.
The Norfolk Carnyx is incredibly rare in that it is a complete instrument, with two mouthpieces (slightly larger than French horn size, and with very thin rims, which would have felt very uncomfortable for lengthy performances!). It was buried in an extremely careful way, with the carnyx covered (perhaps symbolically protected) by a collection of shield bosses, along with an even more rare boar’s head standard (which is an artefact that has never been found in Britain before).
The significance and importance of the Norfolk Carnyx cannot be underestimated – whilst we don’t know if it did belong to Boudica (the area it was found in is part of the Iceni tribe territory), we can say with certainty that it was extremely important to the people who took such care in its burial. Sections of the tubing have been deliberately cut or bent, perhaps to prevent anyone from playing it in the afterlife, and the specific items it is buried with are as unique as the carnyx itself.
Wow! So how long had it been in the ground?
Carnyces are Iron Age instruments. So the Norfolk Carnyx was probably buried between the end of the 1st Century BCE and the beginning of the 1st Century CE, but it might well have been played and used for many years before that.
I’m working with one of the main conservators in charge of the project, Jonathan Clark – he's featured on Digging for Britain in the episode I am playing in, with a small brush, tentatively removing some soil from the carnyx’s (very impressive) eyebrow. To me, that must be the most terrifying job imaginable, as the Norfolk Carnyx has lain dormant below ground for around two thousand years, and is the best preserved carnyx the world has ever seen.
It’s incredibly intact, with mouthpieces, head and tube sections, which no other Carnyx ever found has all together. One false move, and a crucial piece of history is completely destroyed – good thing Jonathan is a world expert!
What were your first interactions with ancient horns?
I was first inspired by seeing John Kenny (now a friend and colleague) play at the Guildhall during my master’s degree. He lined up an array of instruments, including an Alphorn as well as the Deskford Carnyx which John mainly plays; it was just tremendous. I mean, the sound of the Carnyx was just so reverberant. They’re such dramatic instruments; I think the theatrical side of me thought, I can’t leave this. I can’t not do this.
So, I set about learning the Alphorn straight away, and since then I have been building up a profile of lots of other specialist instruments, which have been really exciting to work on for major projects for film and TV.
I guess you didn’t start out thinking that it was going to be financially rewarding?
No, I initially just wanted to find out more and just be able to try the instruments for myself, but if you go down a performing niche, you can often make work for yourself. And yes, fortuitously, I have found that to be the case! I’m quite a thorough person, so I don’t like trying something without looking into it and learning a bit more.
So, having had a go at the alphorn, and then the Roman cornu; the lituus, which is also Roman, and a spot of carnyx, I thought, wow, these are wonderful instruments. I loved playing them and wanted to find out more about the historical context of where they came from. And the historical side is, I think, every bit as thrilling and fascinating as the instruments themselves.
What I love is that for the majority of the projects I do now, it’s someone booking me who wants the whole package. They want the instrument, they want the sound, but they also want to know that they are played by someone who knows what they’re talking about. I know something about their original history and usage. I know about their design, manufacture and metallurgy. I know a bit about their life in the world of the Iron Age and early Roman Britain and Europe, as well as their deposition or burial, so I can confidently talk about the instruments across these different fields.
And were they all basically communication tools used for signalling and that kind of thing?
My PhD is rooted in the idea that there’s more to it than that. That’s not the title, but the general thrust is that these are incredibly complex instruments, probably with extremely complex uses within the societies they came from. Unfortunately, in written accounts, they are simply signalling instruments. Most of them are just categorised as ‘war trumpets’.
If we went into a school to do a horn demo, we’d probably play a fanfare, and say we used horns to communicate and signal, especially in battle.
Exactly, and it's a really mysterious area because there is so little written or documented about them. The only major written records we’ve got are Roman accounts of battles with Celtic warriors across Europe and Britain.
People often assume that the carnyx is a ‘war trumpet’, because of the way that the Romans described it and how the source material is translated. Often, if an artefact is found by an archaeologist, they will not be a professional musician. So if they see a mouthpiece, the mouthpiece looks like any other. The trumpet is one of the most common brass instruments, so therefore they might think it’s a trumpet mouthpiece. As a musician, I’m in a very privileged and unusual position to be able to look a bit deeper or more closely at these things and say, well, hold on a minute. Perhaps it wasn’t just a military trumpet. Perhaps there is more to it than that.
All carnyces have some similarities, which include extremely complex manufacturing techniques. To make them is really difficult (even by modern manufacturing methods) and they often involve complex alloys of brass and bronze, with casting and soldering techniques that are still impressive today. They often have really intricate details like enamelled eyes, or repoussé decoration, and often have fragile ears and a decorated crest or teeth.
A major part of carnyx design is that it is, ultimately, an animalistic head on top of a long tube, which means that they are quite delicate. So the idea that you would use this complex, symbolic, precious instrument only in battle, to me just doesn’t quite make sense. And that then raises questions: where does the carnyx live? Do you put it on a wall? Under a bed? Why does it resemble a ferocious dragon or wild boar? There is a huge ritualistic and socio-cultural significance to the carnyx that is only starting to be explored.
We can find clues in the way that the instruments are deposited and buried at the end of their lives. In the Iron Age, there were huge votive depositions into water, where precious metals in particular were buried. Carnyx fragments have been found in marshy or boggy areas, with other metal deposits indicating that they might have been ritually deposited.
The Norfolk instrument has been buried so carefully. The complexity of its ‘death’ as an instrument, with its burial beneath shield bosses and alongside the boar’s head standard, shows that it’s not just perished in battle or been cast aside. It’s been really carefully buried in a way that suggests that it is of great importance to whoever buried it; there's a lot of meaning and ritual in what they've done.
The carnyx seems to be the instrument that grabs our attention? Is this the flag-bearer for ancient horns?
I suppose it’s the most dramatic, because of its appearance, and having to play it so high in the air. But all of the horns have their own ‘more to it than meets the eye’ story. For example, the lituus, which is one of the first ancient horns that I ever learned to play, looks a bit like a miniature alphorn made of bronze, with the bell resting on the ground as you play it.
The idea is that it’s a conduit up to the heavens, so that whoever is playing it is the medium between heaven and earth, with the instrument helping to tell the future. The lituus was used by the Roman augurs, and sometimes the records describe it as a curved stick, like a J. The augur would hold it up to the sky and carve out an imaginary square. If vultures flew over the square in the right direction, the auspices were really good but if they didn’t, that was bad news!
There’s one copy made by a brilliant colleague and friend of mine, Peter Holmes, of an instrument called the ‘Pian de Civita Lituus’ found in Tarquinia. And that was found buried underneath the entrance to a sacred space, alongside a folded shield and the body of a small child. It was bent ritually into three and the mouthpiece end had been nailed shut; the instrument had effectively been made mute. There’s great significance to that. To go to that much effort, to bend the bronze, is really difficult – there's such a story there.
And I assume the composers that you work with are really fascinated by the historical significance of these instruments?
Yes! What has been really nice has been developing a much more collaborative way of working with composers. I have just finished a project with a wonderful composer about Pompeii. And in Pompeii, they actually found, not a cornu in the actual metal because the eruption of Vesuvius had been so hot, but the outline of it, perfectly preserved in ash. So it’s been possible to make a reconstruction instrument of a Pompeiian cornu. And the Pompeiian cornu is much larger and more elaborate than any other cornu we know of; it’s like a gigantic natural horn to play and you’ll be able to hear it on this soundtrack very soon!
But composers don’t quite know what these instruments sound like, or what they can do. A surprising aspect of something like the cornu, is that even though it’s huge, the bell is really small. So it's very directional; the sound isn’t that loud compared to a modern brass instrument bell, which is designed for maximum volume.
Peter Holmes said to me years ago, and it really stuck with me, that the ancient world would have been really quiet, with none of the extraneous noise we have today. It was a quiet place, so even something that sounds relatively quiet compared to a modern-day brass instrument, would probably have sounded extremely loud in that period.
I’ve never thought of that.
Again, I feel it gives fuel to the fire of my argument that these are not just war trumpets. But I think what’s been lovely for me working on films with composers, is that they now trust me to be part of the collaborative process. They don't know what’s going to come out of the end of the bell; they have to trust that I do! So they say ‘this is the pitch or effect we want, Letty; what can you give us that will match this?’
I have perfect pitch, which is super handy with these instruments, because the notes don’t fall into a harmonic series that you might expect. You have to learn what the note sounds like with muscle and aural memory, and then I try to play this memory, which is a method that works really well for me as an artist.
I suppose, without the big bell, without the reverberations, the slots must be quite small where the actual note you want to hit is?
They’re really small, but it also just doesn’t feel the same as the modern horn to play. Further down the harmonics, there is often more pitch bending possible, and the instrument doesn’t behave in quite the same way that you would expect. You’d think they'd have a fundamental that would be a nice, big, fat, rich note that you could really hammer, but you often can’t. You’ve got to feel your way into the fundamental; it’s actually the higher pitches, that you would think might be a bit less sturdy, which are way easier to come straight in on. It’s often very counterintuitive. What I love is the same thing that Anneke Scott has always said, that whenever she has a new instrument, she’s got to kind of ‘meet the instrument’ and see what it wants to say; she can’t impose her will on it necessarily.
And I think that’s exactly the same as I feel about these ancient horns. I can try and play a melody, sure, but it’s not going to work unless the instrument wants it to.
So you’re breathing new life into these old instruments?
When these ancient fragments of instruments are found, originating from thousands of years ago, you can see them and sometimes you can touch them. You can even get an idea of what their world tasted and smelled like from modern experimental archaeology, but you can’t ever hear them. And it’s this sense that is such a joy to explore, even if it is only a distant echo of what the original might have sounded like.
These instruments have somehow survived through millennia and now the sound of them can be heard in the modern world. I am delighted to be featured on the soundtracks of films such as Gladiator II, The Northman and Nosferatu, and John Kenny is on the video game Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, all of which have been consumed by millions of people worldwide. I’ve even recently done an advert for Nike sportswear in the Italian alps with lots of famous footballers!
So most people reading this article and certainly going to the cinema would have heard some of these instruments that I play. They will have heard the carnyx, they'll have heard the cornu, they've probably heard conch shells and cow horns. They just don’t know it. And what I really love is taking my very niche knowledge about these really niche things, and then putting it into a mass market where anyone can enjoy them. It feels like you're sharing something that has been part of human history for millennia.
These are not my instruments; these are instruments that I’m fascinated by that come from a distant humanity. They are part of all of our history and it is a privilege for me to be able to share in their future.