Isaac Shieh

The Horn Player Editor Richard Steggall talks to Isaac Shieh about his fascinating new album for natural horn, Caprice Reimagined 

Can you tell us how a Kiwi horn player with a Chinese background ended up doing a PhD at the RAM?

I initially moved to the UK to study natural horn with Anneke Scott at the Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama, and later with Roger Montgomery at the Royal Academy of Music. During my time at the Academy as a Professional Diploma student, I went to the RAM PhD open day. Their doctoral programme really appealed to me in the sense that the department focuses on practice-led research, and it felt like a safe space for me to pursue a project that would be a little bit outside of the “norm”. I was particularly inspired by Amy Jolly’s presentation, in which she commissioned a series of new works for cello based on Britten’s Tema “Sacher”. 

I think that was the lightbulb moment for me. I have always been interested in new music. In fact, I started my undergraduate studies as a composer. So it made sense for me to combine my love for natural horn and new music, and commission new works for the instrument. I wasn’t confident that I could do a project as ambitious as Caprice Reimagined on my own outside of a music institution, so I applied to the Academy PhD programme with the sole intention to commission and record a series of new works for natural horn (I mean I know I would also get a PhD out of the process but that wasn’t the primary motivation)!

When did you first encounter the 12 Gallay Caprices? Were they pieces that you studied as a student?

I was introduced to Gallay’s 12 Studies Op. 57 by my first horn teacher when I was 10. I started learning them on the modern horn, and soon after, I moved on to his Caprices. I didn’t know that they were intended for natural horn until I started learning the natural horn nine years later! I have always been fond of Gallay’s music and I feel like these pieces have played a role in my development as a horn player, so it made sense for me to learn them once I became competent enough on the natural horn to attempt them.

Why did you chose these pieces to inspire new works?

Gallay’s Caprices represent a significant part of my personal horn journey as well as serving as a benchmark of the virtuosic standard during the heyday of natural horn playing, so I wanted to commission 12 new works to mirror the Gallay set. I hoped the new commissions would reflect what is possible on the natural horn now, and what could be standard practice in the foreseeable future. 

I guess that each composer needed help writing for the natural horn? How closely did you work with them as they developed their pieces?

It was important to me that all of the composers I engaged and collaborated with had little to no experience writing for the horn, modern or natural. I wanted outsider perspectives on the instrument’s capabilities, whether that be technical, musical, sonic, or otherwise. As such, I created a series of videos that covered a range of topics related to the natural horn, and from that point, different composers chose to work differently. 

Some of the composers chose to work really collaboratively. I think one of my favourite collaborations was with Dai Fujikura, in which he sent me short notational materials with instructions like “as wild as possible” or “the more out of tune, the better”, and I replied with video responses. He extracted and sampled sounds he liked from the videos and this process was repeated until we had a complete piece constructed. The whole collaboration was done on WhatsApp and the final notated score was the last thing we worked on together. The collaboration with Grace-Evangeline Mason was also quite hands-on in that we workshopped through all the notated material and reworked a lot of the passages to make them more musically evocative from a composition perspective or more practical from a performance perspective. For me, it was about respecting Grace’s intentions whilst providing her with ideas on how I can best realise those compositional designs on the natural horn. 

On the other hand, some composers chose to hand me a completed score after a few initial workshops. I think one of the more extreme examples was with James B. Wilson, where I hadn’t seen any notated material until he handed me a complete draft. We were exploring ideas such as the Doppler effect in all our previous workshops, so I was not anticipating something so technical and chromatic! That was really fun, though, since it was almost like he was testing me to see how I would tackle the challenges, and only stepped in if he felt I needed permission to exert interpretive freedom when solving certain issues. 

Why do you feel it’s important to create new music for a historical instrument?

For me, I was drawn to learning and playing the natural horn because of its unique idiosyncrasies as well as the challenges it poses to someone learning the instrument. I like to think I am not the only one motivated by these reasons to learn the instrument. As such, I wanted to commission new music that reflect the current capabilities of its players and aesthetics that reflect our time. Ultimately, I wanted works that reflect what it means to be a 21st-century natural horn player.

On a more personal note, I fell in love with the natural horn, and it is my voice. That being said, I struggled to relate to a lot of the existing repertoire for the natural horn. I feel like I can’t “sing” through them. The new works reflect my relationship with my instrument, with music, and with the people around me. Just as the natural horn is an “imperfect” instrument full of its own idiosyncrasies, the fruits of these collaborations reflect my own characteristics and quirks. 

What are the biggest challenges that the new (and old) pieces present? Which of the new pieces pushes you the most technically?

I think different people find different aspects of natural horn playing to be easier or harder. One of the benefits of commissioning twelve different composers is that I ended up with twelve distinct works that have different appeals and challenges. Dai Fujikura’s ele is very athletic, whilst Electra Perivolaris’s The Mastic Orchard hovers consistently in the mid-high range with lots of high-note entries. Michael Finnissy’s Six Caprices and James B. Wilson’s Chroma-Maxima are both very technical pieces that push my right-hand technique. Lloyd Coleman’s Sgraffito and Timo Andres’s Loud Ciphers really made me work hard on finding expressivity through articulation. Scott Wollschleger’s YOU ARE PERFECT JUST AS YOU ARE is really difficult technically with all the microtones and inflections surrounding the 11th and 13th partials, and Georgia Scott’s The Ghost in the Machine expanded my musicianship through the use of live electronics. 

If a natural horn player wanted to approach these new works, are there any that make good starting points?

Perhaps a really good general starting point is Amanda Cole’s Fabric of the Universe, which explores the open partials of a C basso crook. Robin Haigh’s DOCK LEAF is a fairly simple yet charming piece. That being said, I don’t personally find either of those pieces particularly easy, perhaps because of their simplicity. 

I have personally performed Grace-Evangeline Mason’s In the Garden of a Museum and Rockey Sun Keting’s Chuān II more than other pieces. I think they are pieces that are accessible to both performers and audiences alike, and are really rewarding to play! They are also pieces that are musically challenging and my interpretations of these two works have grown over the years.

Are there any of the new works that you are most excited by? Can you see them becoming recital pieces for advanced players?

I’m really excited by all the works to be honest! But if I had to pick one, it would be Scott Wollschleger’s YOU ARE PERFECT JUST AS YOU ARE. It’s such an incredible piece for natural horn quartet that utilises the instrument to its fullest extent and contains some of the most imaginative and beautiful sounds. I would definitely love to see this piece, along with Timo Andres’s Loud Ciphers, performed live at some point in the future. 

I think the remaining solo pieces could all become recital pieces for advanced players in the future. It is certainly my hope that other players will take them on and have their own interpretations on these wonderful works; it brings me joy whenever I hear from a composer telling me horn players have reached out to ask for the music or have bought copies! I think some are more feasible from technical and programming perspectives, but I think they all deserve to be performed and enjoyed by others. 

Where can we listen to or buy your album? Is the sheet music of the new works available?

You can buy the album on New Focus Recording’s website or on Bandcamp. It’s also available on various streaming platforms, such as Spotify, Apple Music, and Tidal to name a few. Some of the works have been published already either by external publishers or by the composers themselves. I have attached links where you can buy the album and the scores on my website, but I would also recommend getting in touch with the composers themselves. They are all super lovely people and would love their works to be played. 

Do you have a plan for a next recording project?

Absolutely! This project is the first step of hopefully many to come. I think I needed to know what the natural horn and I are capable of doing on our own, and Caprice Reimagined helped me realise my artistic potential and gave me clarity on future artistic directions.

My current project is actually on creating a triptych of films that explore lived experiences of disability through dance and music. I have already made two of them as part of my residency with Paraorchestra featuring original music composed by me, and I am hoping to make the third one sometime soon to complete the triptych.

In terms of a more “traditional” recording project, I have started collaborating with other musicians to create collaborative works. It’s still very early days, but the direction for the next recording project is very much one that focuses on how the natural horn and I interact with other musicians. I also have plans for creating new works for chamber ensemble, and ultimately, to commission natural horn concertos.

Back to Interviews